APR dogbone insert / DV+
#1
Posted 02 August 2019 - 08:18 PM
First off as many of you will be familiar with the Dog bone Stainless steel insert by APR together with the 034 upper insert, this combo was recommended to me by Brian (Fivepotfan)
Fitting was a doddle, although engine undertray needs removing because the actual dog done mount needs removing to fit the upper insert.
After being pushed up into place with grease applied to aid fitment.
Dog mount back on
APR insert lubed & fitted
Started the car up and no noticeable extra vibrations.
Out on the road there is much improvement in the gear changes, they seem crisper now before I’d noticed some transmission ‘slop’ had creeped in, now that has gone.
I can ‘feel’ the engine more now too which adds to the experience of driving the RS.
On the whole the front feels a lot tighter overall.
Worthwhile mod for £110 and half hour fitting.
The GFB DV+.
More involved fit, but the promise of sharper throttle response and less boost lost was too to much to resist.
To aid fitting I took out my air box setup mainly to get at the bottom Torx bolt.
Easy to fit though, a smear of oil on the piston to ensure smooth movement and push on to the factory solenoid then refit with the new longer bolts.
Is it worth it ?
Well I don’t detect an instant improvement in anything really but will update at a later date when I’ve had more time with it on.
#2
Posted 03 August 2019 - 06:39 AM
Decided on a few choice upgrades this week.
First off as many of you will be familiar with the Dog bone Stainless steel insert by APR together with the 034 upper insert, this combo was recommended to me by Brian (Fivepotfan)
Fitting was a doddle, although engine undertray needs removing because the actual dog done mount needs removing to fit the upper insert.
After being pushed up into place with grease applied to aid fitment.
Dog mount back on
APR insert lubed & fitted
Started the car up and no noticeable extra vibrations.
Out on the road there is much improvement in the gear changes, they seem crisper now before I’d noticed some transmission ‘slop’ had creeped in, now that has gone.
I can ‘feel’ the engine more now too which adds to the experience of driving the RS.
On the whole the front feels a lot tighter overall.
Worthwhile mod for £110 and half hour fitting.
The GFB DV+.
More involved fit, but the promise of sharper throttle response and less boost lost was too to much to resist.
To aid fitting I took out my air box setup mainly to get at the bottom Torx bolt.
Easy to fit though, a smear of oil on the piston to ensure smooth movement and push on to the factory solenoid then refit with the new longer bolts.
Is it worth it ?
Well I don’t detect an instant improvement in anything really but will update at a later date when I’ve had more time with it on.
For the novice what is the DV+ supposed to do?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
#3
Posted 03 August 2019 - 06:56 AM
For the novice what is the DV+ supposed to do?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
The solenoid coil itself from the factory-fitted valve is great (the ECU opens it faster than any pneumatic valve so why replace it?), but the weak point however is the valve mechanism itself. So GFB’s DV+ solves this problem by replacing just the valve parts with an anodized billet aluminum housing fitted with a brass piston machined to exacting tolerances.
Other manufacturers’ products involve replacing the entire system with a traditional pneumatic valve, requiring long vacuum hose runs, additional parts for tapping into the intake manifold vacuum, plus either a different solenoid valve to actuate the pneumatic valve or a ballast resistor to plug into the OE wiring loom. All these additional items result in a product that is slower, less responsive, more expensive and takes much longer to install.
GFB’s DV+ solution on the other hand is more responsive, less expensive, easier to install, and doesn't cause compressor surge/turbo flutter. Oh, and it doesn't require different springs or frequent re-builds.
- Retains the factory solenoid coil for seamless integration
- Replaces plastic valve parts with metal for reliability and strength on chipped engines
- Direct-fit replacement with GFB’s TMS benefits
- Exclusive “pilot-actuated” valve mechanism for rapid response at high boost
Many late-model European cars use ECU controlled solenoid-type diverter valves. This is a good concept because the valve can react very quickly and it only opens when it needs to.
However, there are some problems with these valves. There are typically two types of solenoid-actuated diverter valves found standard on VAG and European cars, both of which have their shortcomings.
Common OE Problem #1
- The diaphragm types are commonly known to rupture, especially when boost and temperature are increased as a result of chip tuning.
Common OE Problem #2
- The plastic piston-type leaks far more than most people realize (by design, not from wear), and doesn't always close after a high-boost gear shift.
Additionally, in both cases, the solenoid on the OE diverter is directly connected to the valve mechanism, which is not ideal because neither it nor the return spring are strong enough to open and close the valve reliably at high boost.
With problems like this, you can see why other aftermarket manufacturers assume the best solution is to replace the factory diverter entirely. Unfortunately though, whilst their replacement kits might be stronger than the factory diverter, their slower response speed and lower flow do not justify the extra cost and complexity - more of a compromise than a solution.
Standard plastic Diverter valve
Edited by T-800, 03 August 2019 - 06:58 AM.
#4
Posted 03 August 2019 - 07:19 AM
The solenoid coil itself from the factory-fitted valve is great (the ECU opens it faster than any pneumatic valve so why replace it?), but the weak point however is the valve mechanism itself. So GFB’s DV+ solves this problem by replacing just the valve parts with an anodized billet aluminum housing fitted with a brass piston machined to exacting tolerances.
Other manufacturers’ products involve replacing the entire system with a traditional pneumatic valve, requiring long vacuum hose runs, additional parts for tapping into the intake manifold vacuum, plus either a different solenoid valve to actuate the pneumatic valve or a ballast resistor to plug into the OE wiring loom. All these additional items result in a product that is slower, less responsive, more expensive and takes much longer to install.
GFB’s DV+ solution on the other hand is more responsive, less expensive, easier to install, and doesn't cause compressor surge/turbo flutter. Oh, and it doesn't require different springs or frequent re-builds.
- Retains the factory solenoid coil for seamless integration
- Replaces plastic valve parts with metal for reliability and strength on chipped engines
- Direct-fit replacement with GFB’s TMS benefits
- Exclusive “pilot-actuated” valve mechanism for rapid response at high boost
Many late-model European cars use ECU controlled solenoid-type diverter valves. This is a good concept because the valve can react very quickly and it only opens when it needs to.
However, there are some problems with these valves. There are typically two types of solenoid-actuated diverter valves found standard on VAG and European cars, both of which have their shortcomings.
Common OE Problem #1
- The diaphragm types are commonly known to rupture, especially when boost and temperature are increased as a result of chip tuning.
Common OE Problem #2
- The plastic piston-type leaks far more than most people realize (by design, not from wear), and doesn't always close after a high-boost gear shift.
Additionally, in both cases, the solenoid on the OE diverter is directly connected to the valve mechanism, which is not ideal because neither it nor the return spring are strong enough to open and close the valve reliably at high boost.
With problems like this, you can see why other aftermarket manufacturers assume the best solution is to replace the factory diverter entirely. Unfortunately though, whilst their replacement kits might be stronger than the factory diverter, their slower response speed and lower flow do not justify the extra cost and complexity - more of a compromise than a solution.
gfbdv+.jpg
gfbvalve.jpg
Standard plastic Diverter valve
s-l300.jpg
Thankyou very informative
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
#5
Posted 03 August 2019 - 03:50 PM
I have considered one for mine, I did read some posts online of them starting to stick over time or leak worse than stock from new. Not sure how common this is or how true.
Edited by MarkMac-RS3, 03 August 2019 - 03:50 PM.
#6
Posted 04 August 2019 - 08:07 AM
#7
Posted 04 August 2019 - 07:42 PM
Decided on a few choice upgrades this week.
First off as many of you will be familiar with the Dog bone Stainless steel insert by APR together with the 034 upper insert, this combo was recommended to me by Brian (Fivepotfan)
Fitting was a doddle, although engine undertray needs removing because the actual dog done mount needs removing to fit the upper insert.
After being pushed up into place with grease applied to aid fitment.
Dog mount back on
APR insert lubed & fitted
Started the car up and no noticeable extra vibrations.
Out on the road there is much improvement in the gear changes, they seem crisper now before I’d noticed some transmission ‘slop’ had creeped in, now that has gone.
I can ‘feel’ the engine more now too which adds to the experience of driving the RS.
On the whole the front feels a lot tighter overall.
Worthwhile mod for £110 and half hour fitting.
The GFB DV+.
More involved fit, but the promise of sharper throttle response and less boost lost was too to much to resist.
To aid fitting I took out my air box setup mainly to get at the bottom Torx bolt.
Easy to fit though, a smear of oil on the piston to ensure smooth movement and push on to the factory solenoid then refit with the new longer bolts.
Is it worth it ?
Well I don’t detect an instant improvement in anything really but will update at a later date when I’ve had more time with it on.
Sean
I replaced my dogbone mount the same as yours recently. Did you manage to tighten the big bolt to Audi specs ? 130 Nm + 90*
Catalunya Red ,Heated rear window,Power steering,Wireless (with FM),Seat belts,Servo assisted brakes.Pneumatic tyres. Disc brakes.
#8
Posted 04 August 2019 - 08:17 PM
Sean
I replaced my dogbone mount the same as yours recently. Did you manage to tighten the big bolt to Audi specs ? 130 Nm + 90*
Not the full 90 deg no as I reused the original bolt.
More like 45 deg.
Seemed overkill to me anyway.
#9
Posted 04 August 2019 - 11:15 PM
Not the full 90 deg no as I reused the original bolt.
More like 45 deg.
Seemed overkill to me anyway.
Sean did your bottom stop you at 45' when doing the bolt up ? 🤔
I got the full 90' when we reused the bolt after fitting a Powerflex dog bone insert the other weekend to a friend's TTRS.😂
You do have a point about the torque figurer + the 90' mate.👍
Dell.
#10
Posted 05 August 2019 - 06:12 AM
Sean did your bottom stop you at 45' when doing the bolt up ?
I got the full 90' when we reused the bolt after fitting a Powerflex dog bone insert the other weekend to a friend's TTRS.
You do have a point about the torque figurer + the 90' mate.
Dell.
I didn’t feel it needed it Dell.
With it being a angle tightened bolt I also didn’t want to push my luck because 130 and 45 is incredibly tight.
#11
Posted 05 August 2019 - 07:31 AM
I didn’t feel it needed it Dell.
With it being a angle tightened bolt I also didn’t want to push my luck because 130 and 45 is incredibly tight.
I agree Sean 👍
Dell.
#12
Posted 05 August 2019 - 04:24 PM
I didn’t feel it needed it Dell.
With it being a angle tightened bolt I also didn’t want to push my luck because 130 and 45 is incredibly tight.
I couldn`t get 130 plus 90*. It was almost at the point of snapping my 24" strongarm.
Catalunya Red ,Heated rear window,Power steering,Wireless (with FM),Seat belts,Servo assisted brakes.Pneumatic tyres. Disc brakes.
#13
Posted 05 August 2019 - 04:48 PM
I couldn`t get 130 plus 90*. It was almost at the point of snapping my 24" strongarm.
It doesn’t help when the bolt feels like that is going to happen
#14
Posted 05 August 2019 - 05:32 PM
GFP DV+ ordered!
The solenoid coil itself from the factory-fitted valve is great (the ECU opens it faster than any pneumatic valve so why replace it?), but the weak point however is the valve mechanism itself. So GFB’s DV+ solves this problem by replacing just the valve parts with an anodized billet aluminum housing fitted with a brass piston machined to exacting tolerances.
Other manufacturers’ products involve replacing the entire system with a traditional pneumatic valve, requiring long vacuum hose runs, additional parts for tapping into the intake manifold vacuum, plus either a different solenoid valve to actuate the pneumatic valve or a ballast resistor to plug into the OE wiring loom. All these additional items result in a product that is slower, less responsive, more expensive and takes much longer to install.
GFB’s DV+ solution on the other hand is more responsive, less expensive, easier to install, and doesn't cause compressor surge/turbo flutter. Oh, and it doesn't require different springs or frequent re-builds.
- Retains the factory solenoid coil for seamless integration
- Replaces plastic valve parts with metal for reliability and strength on chipped engines
- Direct-fit replacement with GFB’s TMS benefits
- Exclusive “pilot-actuated” valve mechanism for rapid response at high boost
Many late-model European cars use ECU controlled solenoid-type diverter valves. This is a good concept because the valve can react very quickly and it only opens when it needs to.
However, there are some problems with these valves. There are typically two types of solenoid-actuated diverter valves found standard on VAG and European cars, both of which have their shortcomings.
Common OE Problem #1
- The diaphragm types are commonly known to rupture, especially when boost and temperature are increased as a result of chip tuning.
Common OE Problem #2
- The plastic piston-type leaks far more than most people realize (by design, not from wear), and doesn't always close after a high-boost gear shift.
Additionally, in both cases, the solenoid on the OE diverter is directly connected to the valve mechanism, which is not ideal because neither it nor the return spring are strong enough to open and close the valve reliably at high boost.
With problems like this, you can see why other aftermarket manufacturers assume the best solution is to replace the factory diverter entirely. Unfortunately though, whilst their replacement kits might be stronger than the factory diverter, their slower response speed and lower flow do not justify the extra cost and complexity - more of a compromise than a solution.
gfbdv+.jpg
gfbvalve.jpg
Standard plastic Diverter valve
s-l300.jpg
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
#15
Posted 17 August 2019 - 06:58 PM
Finally got round to fitting the DV+ on the missus’ M135i. The picture makes it look like there is a lot of room. Three and a half hours to change it and a lot of swearing say other wise 😂
#16
Posted 17 August 2019 - 08:55 PM
Any thoughts on the DV+ so far Sean?
Finally got round to fitting the DV+ on the missus’ M135i. The picture makes it look like there is a lot of room. Three and a half hours to change it and a lot of swearing say other wise
No real difference I can tell to be honest.
#17
Posted 25 August 2019 - 01:46 PM
Anybody know which one I need ?
#18
Posted 25 August 2019 - 03:01 PM
You need to check under the car really.Both of these are in the basket apparently there’s two versions on AwesomeGTI
Anybody know which one I need ?
Mine was version 2
#19
Posted 25 August 2019 - 03:15 PM
You need to check under the car really.
Mine was version 2
We should in theory be the same shouldn’t we both glacier white FL
#20
Posted 25 August 2019 - 03:18 PM
We should in theory be the same shouldn’t we both glacier white FL
colour has no influence here
Depends where the subframe was assembled I’m told although I’ve yet to come across a version 1.