Why does the 8p get a bad rap?
#1
Posted 07 February 2019 - 08:42 PM
Previously had a B7 RS4, Mkv and Mkiv Golf R32’s, FN2 Type R, Clio 172.
The 8p is my fave! Not particularly noticed the often-mentioned Understeer.
Maybe not so much on this forum but on other Audi forums and in press reviews, the 8p doesn’t seem to be well regarded compared to the 8v, or in general. Are they really that different? And why the 8p poor reviews?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
#2
Posted 07 February 2019 - 08:56 PM
I’ve had em all, loved owning all of them.Had my 8p for a couple of months now. Hands down best car I’ve owned as an overall package.
Previously had a B7 RS4, Mkv and Mkiv Golf R32’s, FN2 Type R, Clio 172.
The 8p is my fave! Not particularly noticed the often-mentioned Understeer.
Maybe not so much on this forum but on other Audi forums and in press reviews, the 8p doesn’t seem to be well regarded compared to the 8v, or in general. Are they really that different? And why the 8p poor reviews?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
#3
Posted 07 February 2019 - 08:58 PM
No idea on this one - I had an 8P 2L S-Line for 2 years and 35,000 miles and it was bomb proof. Great car.
Currently on a demolition derby with the Mrs and, apart from the panel damage (new rear door and rear bumper so far), still bomb proof.
#4
Posted 07 February 2019 - 09:29 PM
I used to be on a lot of Audi biased forums, and I do wonder If some if the bigger RS boys at the time of the 8P launch felt threatened by the performance of their smaller brother, I bet a lot of the doubters never tried one.
#5
Posted 07 February 2019 - 09:56 PM
#6
Posted 07 February 2019 - 11:51 PM
Agree with you Dell, just love it, always puts a smile on my face, even after nearly 7 years
Graham
#7
Posted 08 February 2019 - 07:55 AM
#8
Posted 08 February 2019 - 08:23 AM
I've had an 8P & an 8V & although they are both special, the 8P just felt that somthing differant & more sturdly built than the 8V
My Wife also has an 8P & I still love to drive it whenever I get the opportunity. The 8p is somthing more special now as there were less of them built than the 8V series.
MY17 Panther Black RS 7 Performance | Black Pack | Carbon Interior | 21" DS black wheels fitted with MPS4's tyres | Dynamic Pack | Audi Connect | Advanced Key + boot opening | Audi phone box with wireless charging | Audi smartphone interface | Dynamic Mirror Indicators | Parking pack | Feature programming changes | EM Tuning interior LED light update | Thinkware F800 pro + Rear Dash Cam |
Wife: MY12 Daytona Grey RS3 | Bucket seats with grey stitching | Heated seats | Black Styling Pack & Inlays | Black Roof Bars | Privacy glass | RNS-E | Bose sound system | Reversing Sensors | Audi LED number plate lights | EM Tuning LED interior light pack | Cruise Control | Folding, dimming & heated mirrors | Auto Lights & Wipers | Adaptive headlights | Gloss Black Alloys fitted with MPS4's tyres | Thinkware F750 + Rear Dash Cam |
#9
Posted 08 February 2019 - 08:46 AM
The 8P is considered by many as an afterthought by Audi rather than a purposeful RS. The engine was just stuck in, and other aspects of the design were barely given any thought. For example the front arches were flared bolt on's, and the rears were not. Then there was that awful reverse rake on the suspension setup. These are the opinions I had come across at that time.
#10
Posted 08 February 2019 - 09:17 AM
The 8P is considered by many as an afterthought by Audi rather than a purposeful RS. The engine was just stuck in, and other aspects of the design were barely given any thought. For example the front arches were flared bolt on's, and the rears were not. Then there was that awful reverse rake on the suspension setup. These are the opinions I had come across at that time.
The 2750 built 8P RS3 was not an after thought but more of Audi dipping its toe in the water of the financial viability of them building a A3 RS in the up coming 8v MBQ chassis by using the engine,dsg & other shared components from the TTRS.
The carbon composite arches were a necessity to accommodate the option 255 tyres & of course the one off bumper to match the arches.
The main body off the 8v RS3 is no different to say a S-Line model still no one off flared aches like any off it RS big brother's.
The 500 allocated to the UK was so overscribed that Audi made an additional 250 to accommodate.
Without the marketing success of the 8P RS3 you may never have had the privilege to owning a 8v RS3.
Dell.
Edited by RS3Dell, 08 February 2019 - 09:47 AM.
#11
Posted 08 February 2019 - 09:19 AM
I've had um-teen M 3's in the E36, E46 and E92 models and found the RS3 a great car by comparison. It's far less technical and I love the flexibility of sport-back layout. It's quick too with terrific torque. Equally as fast as any M car.
I have to say I do like the later model and think Audi have done a great job with it, particularly the interior with the interactive dash and the layout.
That said the 2012 model I have does appear to be holding it's selling value, by comparison to the purchase price I paid back in 2016!
#12
Posted 08 February 2019 - 09:47 AM
TX.
Sent from my BBB100-2 using Tapatalk
Nardo RS4
#13
Posted 08 February 2019 - 12:03 PM
My 8V didn't understeer in the slightest either. Imho you get some twats throwing the car into corners on a track at silly speeds hence "understeer" which is never seen on the road.
TX.
Sent from my BBB100-2 using Tapatalk
Chris Harris’ video when he had the 8p RS3 against the M135i proved that. Not that he isn’t biased towards BMW’s. . .
He kept throwing the RS3 into corners unsettling it. If I remember right he also thought it had adaptive dampers when he complained about the ride comfort.
#14
Posted 08 February 2019 - 12:15 PM
Agreed Dell.The 2750 built 8P RS3 was not an after thought but more of Audi dipping its toe in the water of the financial viability of them building a A3 RS in the up coming 8v MBQ chassis by using the engine,dsg & other shared components from the TTRS.
The carbon composite arches were a necessity to accommodate the option 255 tyres & of course the one off bumper to match the arches.
The main body off the 8v RS3 is no different to say a S-Line model still no one off flared aches like any off it RS big brother's.
The 500 allocated to the UK was so overscribed that Audi made an additional 250 to accommodate.
Without the marketing success of the 8P RS3 you may never have had the privilege to owning a 8v RS3.
Dell.
TT RS already had the 5 pot since 2009 so it’s now wonder Audi thought let’s create a hyper hatch.
All the 8P needed was the ARB / better springs and decent brake discs to enhance an already great car.
People who slag it off because they haven’t owned one are bonkers.
Having the ‘latest’ thing doesn’t always mean it’s better, look how many owners tweak their 8V / 8V.5
#15
Posted 08 February 2019 - 12:20 PM
Fantastic Cars in fact I like them so much bought my 5th one last year and prefer them over the 8V although technology and design is showing it's age a bit now
#16
Posted 08 February 2019 - 08:11 PM
Fantastic Cars in fact I like them so much bought my 5th one last year and prefer them over the 8V although technology and design is showing it's age a bit now
Similar situation here @Real thing, currently enjoying my second 8p (mileage clocking up already due frequent driving), I prefer 8p to 8v. I literally don’t drive the MK7 R very much. The look and the build of the 8p in my opinion still has a certain presence.
#17
Posted 08 February 2019 - 11:15 PM
Similar situation here @Real thing, currently enjoying my second 8p (mileage clocking up already due frequent driving), I prefer 8p to 8v. I literally don’t drive the MK7 R very much. The look and the build of the 8p in my opinion still has a certain presence.
I see loads of 8v pfl & fl in Aberdeen but when I see an 8p I always do a double take, never see many on the roads.